Single Family Property for Sale in Chilmark, #33587

Single Family Homes - Chilmark, North Chilmark North | 14 Bens Way Chilmark MA
  • Rooms/BD
  • Bath(s)
  • SqF
    3,163 ft²
  • Price


The Jethro Athearn Homestead, circa 1735, is a two and one half story, center-chimney home, relocated from West Tisbury, sensitively restored and updated for modern living in the 1990’s. This five bedroom, three and one half bath home sits on three private acres off North Road, once part of the actor James Cagney’s estate. Period features include seven working fireplaces. Wide pine flooring, antique doors and hardware are found throughout the interior spaces. Glorious terraced gardens, inspired by noted English landscape designer, Gertrude Jekyll, a stone garden house, a fruit orchard and ancient stone walls compliment the antique homestead and provide a captivating setting. There are two outbuildings on the grounds, an 18th century barn and a 4/5 bay carriage house with bath. The property includes an additional abutting eight acres of farmland, surrounded by non-developable open space. The Great Rock Bight Preserve, with miles of walking trails and sandy Vineyard Sound beach, is within walking distance from the house.

Floor 1: Living room with fireplace, keeping room with massive firebox with rear bake oven, buttery, borning room, two full baths, one bedroom, one office or bedroom, kitchen, laundry room.

Floor 2: Three bedrooms, two with fireplaces, keeping room with massive firebox.

Basement: Poured concrete, full height.

Other Buildings: 18th century English style barn and a 4/5 bay carriage house/heated shop with bath, stone garden house. Landscape and gardens protected by deer and rabbit fencing.

Second Dwelling:


Indoor amenities
A/C, Heating - Central
Outdoor amenities

©2018 LINK, All Rights Reserved. Not responsible for misinformation or typographical errors. Prices are subject to change without notice. Listed by: Russell Maloney Real Estate

Inquire about this property

MV Property Location

Listing ID: #33587

  • Year Built: 1735
  • Zoning: RES
  • Flooring: Antique wide plank wood
  • Yard: Mature landscape, terraced gardens
  • Foundation: Poured concrete, 10 inch thickness
  • Water: Well
  • Heating: Gas\FHA